October 8, 2026
Peet's Coffee spent 12 years at 919 Cole Street and closed in January. According to Dan Serot, who owns Finnegans Wake, the landlord's first plan was another coffee shop. The Cole Valley Merchants Association and the Cole Valley Improvement Association, the residents' group, wrote the building owner a joint letter instead. "We said, 'Please, we don't need any more coffee. We need food,'" Serot told the SF Standard in September.
The space is now going to Pasta Supply Co., run by chef Anthony Strong. Strong has lived in Cole Valley for twelve years, and his apartment is a few blocks from the storefront.
That letter shows how Cole Street is changing right now. Most of the new businesses are being opened by people who already live in the neighborhood. The groups that represent merchants and residents have also had a real say in which businesses move in.
Cole Valley's commercial strip is only a block and a half of Cole Street, from Carl to Parnassus. The Standard counted nearly a dozen places to eat there, plus two coffee shops, a dry cleaner, a shipping store, a hardware store, an upscale grocer, a pet shop, a gym, and an urgent care center. On a strip that short, every storefront matters. A third coffee counter would have taken the place of a whole category the block doesn't have yet.
The block's anchors explain why the mix gets this much attention. Cole Hardware opened in 1920. Val de Cole, a liquor store and Legacy Business, has been in operation since the 1930s. Say Cheese has been open for 50 years, and Finnegans Wake marks its 50th anniversary this month. The new arrivals are moving in next door to businesses that have outlasted several generations of neighbors.
The Standard reported that much of the recent change on Cole Street "is coming from within," led by longtime residents. Owner by owner:
Those last three storefronts sit side by side, giving one short stretch of Cole Street a strong neighborhood-business feel. "It's so mom-and-pop," Hoenscheid told the Standard. "You feel like you're in a small town."
Here is what is open, what is coming, and what is still unconfirmed as of the end of September.
The most recent wave of change began a little earlier. Woods Beer and Wine Co. took over the old Reverie space in early 2024, a few months after Blue Barn moved in, and the boutique Rising Star Laundry came after. On Friday nights, people line up down the block for a seat on the Woods back patio.
The Cole Valley Merchants Association only launched in 2023, yet the 919 Cole letter is one of several things it has done. The association worked with SFMTA to move loading zones off the main street and shorten commercial loading hours, which frees up parking for customers. It has also raised money for streetlights and the night markets.
"We've raised money for the streetlights and night markets, and we fixed the parking. I'm really proud." Dan Serot, Finnegans Wake
The association has also helped newcomers who aren't from the neighborhood. Humphries doesn't live in Cole Valley. She went to her first association meeting a few weeks before her planned opening and told the Standard, "Everyone's so supportive, they're so organized."
Strong is paying for the Cole Valley buildout with a crowdfunding campaign instead of a bank loan. Backers who put in $550 get a year of weekly take-home pasta, and backers who put in $4,000 get weekly pasta for life. "We'd rather pay all of them back in pasta than hit up banks for loans," he told the Standard. Eater SF covered the campaign in August. Put together with the landlord letter, it means neighbors are both asking for the restaurant and helping pay to build it.
Luke Spray runs Civic Joy Fund, the nonprofit that organizes markets and pop-ups around the city. He compares Cole Valley to West Portal, which was "a bit sleepy" until local merchants asked, "Why aren't we doing something in our own backyard?"
Angelus, who has run Cole Valley Tavern for years, expects some new competition. He told the Standard his restaurant may take a hit once Lin's restaurant and Pasta Supply Co. open. He admits he doubted Woods' smashburger at first. When he renamed his restaurant in 2022, one customer petitioned him to keep the burger the same. He has made peace with it. "It's a long game," he said. "Ultimately, I think this is going to be great for all of us."
Not every regular is on board yet. Angelus says some of his customers have grumbled about the new coffee shop. He also enjoys the new choices. "My wife and I joke that we've got to get out of Cole Valley this week," he said.
Neighbors are already debating the next change. A group of advocates wants to make the Cole Valley Town Square permanent. The Town Square is the wedge of asphalt on Carl Street between Cole and Clayton, where the N Judah turns off. Three pop-up events in 2025 filled it with more than 500 plants. Green SF Now lists the next steps as city and community approval plus funding, with implementation targeted for 2026 to 2027. The Cole Valley Improvement Association's summer newsletter says some neighbors want it made permanent and others object.
The next dates on the calendar:
The 23rd annual Cole Valley Fair took place on Sunday, September 27. It was presented by the Cole Valley Improvement Association and Sunset Mercantile, with support from the merchants association. The program listed more than 90 vendors, a neighborhood-history photo display, and a block of vintage cars owned by residents.
If you live off Cole Street and are wondering how the new restaurants, shops, and a possible permanent Town Square could affect your home's value, Ilana Minkoff is happy to talk it through over a coffee at Double Black, or a bowl of pasta once 919 Cole opens. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
San Francisco
Buying a home in San Francisco? Explore neighborhoods, local shops, restaurants, home styles, and practical advice from SF REALTOR® Ilana Minkoff.
San Francisco
Holiday traditions, neighborhood favorites, and local businesses worth getting out of the house for.
West Portal
The West Portal Merchants host their annual Halloween Stroll this Saturday, October 31, 4 to 7 p.m. The format hasn't needed updating in years, and that's the actual s… Read more
Strategic Real Estate Advisor
Ilana is a top producing REALTOR® having reached the top 1.5% of REALTORS® nationwide. She is a distinguished San Francisco resident, boasting over twenty-four years of intimate connection with the city, rendering her an unparalleled authority in local real estate. An expert in marketing and negotiation, through hundreds of transactions, she has the depth of experience and breadth of knowledge to guide both buyers and sellers through the process.
Ilana distinguishes herself through her tenacity, mastery of negotiation, unwavering integrity, and meticulous attention to detail, consistently delivering outstanding results for her clients.
Whether buying your first home, selling your tenth home, or somewhere in between, Ilana's goal is to always go above and beyond to exceed your expectations! She wants to ensure such a great experience that you won’t want your friends, family, colleagues, or anyone you know to do a real estate transaction without her.